Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Lancaster LM472 lost 16/17th Jan. 1945


Corporal

Status: Offline
Posts: 13
Date:
Lancaster LM472 lost 16/17th Jan. 1945
Permalink   


Hi people,

Sorry in advance about this being a long post.

I am looking for information about my great uncle who was a member of raf 101 squadron during WWII. His was Flying Officer Frederick Desmond McGonigle, 179064.

Desmond McGonigle.jpg

He was the pilot of Avro Lancaster Mk.III LM472 SR-V2, which was shot down during an operation to bomb the synthetic oil plant near Brux, in Western Czechoslovakia on 16/17 January 1945.  He may have joined the raf in April 1941 but information is a bit unclear at the moment and he may have transferred to the raf in 1943He was a pilot officer by/in 1944 and a flight officer by 3rd January 1945. I am looking for official information, but additionally, if their happens to be anyone who knew him/or any other members of the crew during his/their time in the raf I would be interested in hearing from them.

I am aware that the brother of one of the other crew members (F/Sgt Laurence Collins)is researching this crew and has made contact with the families of all the crew members (most recently my own) except (to date)Beckett and Conroy.

The crew of LM472 SR-V2 consisted of

Name

Service

Trade

Hometown

Age

F/O Frederick McGonigle

RAFVR

Pilot

Glasgow, Scotland

25

Sgt John McDowell

RAFVR

Flight Engineer

County Down, N. Ireland

23

F/Sgt John Knight - POW

RAAF

Navigator

Penshurst,New South Wales, Australia

21

F/Sgt Warren Hart

RAAF

Bomb Aimer

Mackay, Queensland

20

F/Sgt Laurence Collins

RAAF

W/Op/AG

Ballarat, Victoria, Australia

20

Sgt Robert Beckett

RAFVR

Air Gunner

-

-

Sgt Daniel Conroy

RAFVR

Air Gunner

-

-

P/O Jack Armour

RCAF

Special Equipment Operator

Hamilton, Ontario

27

The details as of the crash as I am currently aware (as on this website http://www.bombercrew.com/101/collins.htm)are as follows:

At 1748 hours on 16 January 1945, Lancaster MkIII serial LM472 Code SR-V2 from RAF 101 Squadron, with a crew of eight, took off from Ludford Magna, Lincolnshire, Great Britain, on a bombing operation to attack a synthetic oil plant near Brux, West Czechoslovakia. It was due to return to base, 0247 hours  17 January 1945. The aircraft was part of a total of 231 Lancaster (7 Lancasters from 101 Squadron-equipped with ABC equipment) and 6 Mosquitos (total 237 aircraft), from RAF Bomber Command Nos. 1 and 5 Groups, and, although the raid was considered a complete success, as only one of the 237 aircraft (LM472 code SR-V2) did not return.

The aircraft and crew were posted as missing, and subsequently confirmed as being shot down,with one survivor, over enemy territory. At approximately 2204 hours, 16 January 1945, the burning plane flew very low over the village of Geilsdorf, to such an extent that the villagers, within the village, were in fear of the aircraft crashing into their homes. Apparently the pilots (F.D. McGonigle)intention seemed to be to land in some snow covered fields, but unfortunately, the aircraft clipped some high tension light wires on the edge of the field, about 30 metres from the road between Ruderitz and Geilsdorf, causing the bomb laden plane to explode. Eye witnesses of the incident stated that there was a large whitish explosion seen at 5026N, 1200E, clearly visible in the night sky. This was confirmed by another report, received from the crew of an aircraft from 619 squadron, reporting an explosion at 2209 hours, at the same location-this position corresponds with the place between the villages of Hof and Plauen, where the plane crashed.

Having had a look at the online digital versions of the casualty reports for two of the RAAF members of the crew (Collins and Hart), which are available through the Australian National archives , it would seem that the in the aftermath of the plane not returning that the raf believed that the plane may have been shot down by flak. There was also a report by a crew of possibly seeing a parachute close to bruxbut I think this was a red herring. When John Knight was rescued from the pow camp he stated in his official report that the plane had received fire from an enemy plane (and not flak) and one of the left engines caught fireand to cut the story shortthat the plane blew up just after the captain advised everyone to bail out at c.10, 000 ft having wrestled to keep the plane flying for about two mins. This obviously contradicts the eyewitness accounts but I think the fact that knights head had been split open means that his recollections of the crash may not have been entirely accurate. However, it does raise the question as to whether the plane was shot down by flak or an enemy fighter?

Having looked at the raf raid report http://www.na237.net/raid_report.html for the 16/17th January 1945 it would appear that enemy fighters were encountered/ engaged on the brux run as a Lancaster shot one german plane down en route, which was also when LM472 went down. But this does not answer the question

Does anyone know if there are german documents or reports relating to this incident which would confirm how the plane was shot down? The casualty reports state that german documents containing information about the fate of the aircrew were obtained by the british in the months following the incident but the information quoted is minimal

The information in the casualty reports also state that there was no radio contact between LM472 and either the base or other planes following take offwould this have been standard procedure or unusual for this to have happened?

I also have some further related questions but before I list them I will just like to clarify that I am aware of how to obtain the service records through the RAF Disclosures Section (this will be done in the not too distant future) and I am awaiting a reply from the raf museum as to whether they hold any relevant documentation (it should be in the next week or so).

So with that in mind I am also wondering if anyone would have information about Des service record (I am pretty sure he did his training in Perth, Doncaster and Salisbury, S. Rhodesia) or any information about which sorties Des flew on? One thing I (think I) do know is that he was on leave when D-Day happened and (apparently) he couldnt believe it happened without him.

Some other information I have, which is quite possibly/probably inaccurate states that Des volunteered to fly the brux mission having completed his tour of service as one plane needed a pilot. However, the crew of LM472 were Des usual crew, so this again is contradictoryDid the whole crew in fact volunteer to do one extra flight?

Also would LM472 have been the crews usual plane? I am having trouble establishing on the internet if crews generally flew just one plane or whether it depended on the mission or whether a plane was fit to fly.some of the service records I have seen on the net state that particular crews did their flying in just one or two aircraft, but others seem to have flown in different planes almost every mission.

And finally does anyone know what the nickname of LM472 was and/or what nose art did it have?

I hope some of you out there can help me out!




__________________
THOR!!


Wing Commander

Status: Offline
Posts: 109
Date:
Permalink   

I just had a quick look through the 101 ORB for Dec.44 & Jan 45 and that time we see his crew fly 6 different aircraft
"F" LM161
"V2" LM457
"V2" DV407
"Z" NG129
"W" NG131
"V2" LM472
The letters would leave me to believe they would have been in "C" Flight and "V2", which is not a very common A/C code seems to used by them quite a bit.
I will go through things further and see what I can find out.
Dave Wallace

__________________


Wing Commander

Status: Offline
Posts: 109
Date:
Permalink   

I don't have a date he was posted in to the squadron as the ORB has scant details on movements at that time.He did his trip as a 2nd pilot 15/16.9.44 to Kiel with P/O Neilson and then does 24 more ops with his own crew, failing to return on the last one. If you let me know your email address I can send you some details.
Regards
Dave Wallace

__________________


Corporal

Status: Offline
Posts: 13
Date:
Permalink   

Hi all,


Thanks Dave...most informative...I sent you a pm with e-mail a couple of days ago....thanks a million!!

I have (almost) managed to track down and get in contact with one of the Neilsen crew...


does anybody know if the bomber command ors files are accessible and if they are where and/or through what channels this would/could be possible!??!


any assistance would be greatly appreciated!!


Thor


-- Edited by thorthemighty on Monday 2nd of November 2009 02:12:36 PM

__________________
THOR!!
K for Kitty Crew

Date:
Permalink   

Hi Thor,

Yes, you can obtain ex-crew / crew details ( ORB's) online, from Kew in England and I am lead to believe, from Canada.

In most cases, you can obtain, individual crew operations which may include ......

*   Operation Name.
*   Crew listing.
*   Flight details / duration.
*   Bomb load, to name a few.

There is a costs involved but I can assure you that it is well worth it.

The information may vary from squadron to squadron, depending on how well the records were kept for that particular squadron.

Regards,
John

http://stirlingaircraftsoc.raf38group.org/




__________________


Wing Commander

Status: Offline
Posts: 109
Date:
Permalink   

I never got a pm or email
Dave

__________________


Corporal

Status: Offline
Posts: 13
Date:
Permalink   

thanks a million John...I'll see if I can locate it on the national archives site!!

Dave...I sent it again...hope it gets to you this time...




Thor


-- Edited by thorthemighty on Tuesday 3rd of November 2009 11:02:38 PM

-- Edited by thorthemighty on Tuesday 3rd of November 2009 11:03:24 PM

__________________
THOR!!


Wing Commander

Status: Offline
Posts: 109
Date:
Permalink   

No  email or pm so far Thor - what is your email address?

__________________


Corporal

Status: Offline
Posts: 13
Date:
Permalink   

Hi dave....

this is frustrating...

I don't really want to post my e-mail address on the net...

I thought I had changed my settings so I could accept e-mails/pms, but I just checked and I was mistaken...have changed it now so you should be able to send it to me...however...I'll try send it to you again...


Thor


__________________
THOR!!


Corporal

Status: Offline
Posts: 13
Date:
Permalink   

Dave,


not sure if you saw my white board msg...but check my profile for address


Thor


__________________
THOR!!
Anonymous

Date:
Permalink   

Hi,
the following extract  from the book ' Nachtjagd War Diaries Vol 2'  by Theo Boiten maybe of some interest:-

' The force attacking Brux reported one combat with a night fighter over the target, which was claimed as destroyed and three more combats with Ju88s along the homeward route. The only bomber lost was a 101 Squadron Lancaster LM472, which was hit by gunfire from an unseen aircraft and crashed 800 m. from Geilsdorf, SW of Plauen. The Bomber Command ORS officially assessed the cause of this loss after the war as machine gun fire from a Lancaster.'



Mike.

__________________


Corporal

Status: Offline
Posts: 13
Date:
Permalink   

thanks mike,


i'll try and follow that up!

thor


__________________
THOR!!
K for Kitty Crew

Date:
Permalink   

Hi Thor and everyone,

The Nachtjagd War Diaries Vol 1 & 2, are a fantastic set of books written by Dr Theo Boiten, through Redkite publishing.

If you were to combined the details from these books and Chorleys set of nine volumes, you would have covered just about all the information available to us today.

One covers the Bomber Command, the other, Luftwafle related details. About as conclusive as you can get, if I say so myself.

Regards,
John



__________________
Relation of D Conroy 1881462

Date:
Permalink   

Hi Lads,

 Dan Conroy was my great uncle. He was born in Dublin but I'm not sure which year. I am really intrested in finding out more information on the crew and I was hoping you had some knowledge of the actual crash site. If you do could you  please post it.

Regards,

Cían



__________________


Corporal

Status: Offline
Posts: 13
Date:
Permalink   

hey cian,

 

 

Quite a bit of info has been gathered on the crew etc and the crash site is known. Send a PM and I'll give you me email address. 

 

 

Thor



__________________
THOR!!
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard